- Rev. Thomas Weld, 1738-1744
- Deacon Samuel Nelson, 1744-1751
- Deacon Samuel Warfield, 1744-1751
- Rev. Elisha Fish, 1751-1795
- Rev. Benjamin Wood, 1795-1849
- Rev. William Warren, 1849-1856
- Rev. Andrew J. Willard, 1857-1865
- Rev. Spencer O. Dyer, 1865-1870
- Rev. John E.M. Wright, 1871-1875
- Rev. Francis J. Marsh, 1876-1881
- Rev. Arthur Shirley, 1881-1886
|
- Rev. Almon J. Dyer, 1886-1892
- Rev. Alexander Wiswall, 1892-1904
- Rev. Ernest W. Eldridge, 1904-1907
- Rev. Osmond J. Billings, 1908-1916
- Rev. George E. Russell, 1916-1917
- Rev. William George Poor, 1919-1938
- Rev. Herbert Lombard, 1938-1939
- Rev. William Williams, 1939-1953
- Rev. George F. Tillett, 1953-1962
- Rev. David Raymond, 1962-1968
- Rev. Robert Jackman, 1969-1970
|